
There is a movement in ethnography to pay deeper attention to scents and sounds, flavors and textures - fabrics pressed into skin, burning of hot spices against tongue, mouth-feel of breads and cakes. Many ethnographers record rich visual details and dialogue, but not much else. As if language and images are the only things worth analyzing - not the lightness of a fingertip touch or the burning aromas of herbs, the rhythm of mortar and pestle.
For the past two decades, this has been challenged as a cultural bias, since in many cultures, touch or scent are more compelling. If you describe the ritual dance and translate the song, but forget the incense perfume, you are missing the point. Even in the image-saturated west, we rarely rely on sight alone, despite expressions like, let me see for myself, and I see what you mean. We seek to verify what we see. Cheeks flushed? Let me slide a glass thermometer between your lips. Nor do we accept words without evidence to back them up. You say you love me? Prove it.
Several years ago, I visited the dentist for a severe toothache. My lower right wisdom tooth was pushing up through the gums, and I was hoping for an immediate extraction. As the dentist leaned over my face, she said, "This tooth is infected. I can't pull it until the infection clears." She swirled around in her chair, lifted her prescription pad from a nearby table, and wrote clindamycin in messy scrawl. "Didn't you know it was infected?" She asked, as she handed me the slip. "Couldn't you taste it? I could smell it right away."
Sometimes, I feel so separate from this city, as if everything I see is through a window. Thick glass, the kind that stops all sound, save the muffled sirens of an ambulance or police car. This past week, the feeling has grown more intense, since I started a medication that makes me sensitive to sunlight. The pharmacist directed me to wear sunglasses in the rain. I am supposed to wear a hat and at least 30 SPF sunscreen (to which I am almost always allergic), and if at all possible, to stay indoors between the hours of 10 and 3. Now, I really am watching through windows.
I miss the spicy chicken-and-bok-choy scents of the restaurants in China Town. I miss the texture of the handrails on the Steel Bridge, how they sometimes scrape my palm, sending shrill shocks through my tooth fillings and jaw (and how the towers loom above, filled with potential energy, the counterweights ready to fall and lift the spans so a ship can pass beneath). I miss long walks along the riverfront, lomo crammed deep into my messenger bag, pressing into my hipbone, ready to capture light and shadows so I can share at least one sense of this city with you.
for an exploration of touch and art, visit kelley.
for an exploration of taste and healing, visit wendy.
for an exploration of how senses change (written by an inspiring ethnographer), visit dewi